The Supreme Court has confirmed that that a five-point test applies in respect of identifying whether contracts are ‘contracts of service’ or ‘contracts for service’. Delivering judgment for the Supreme Court, Mr Justice Brian Murray cautioned that the judgment did not bind a
Gillian O'Hanlon BL
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal from a refusal to prohibit the criminal trial of an accused who was 15 at the time of the incident complained of. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice George Birmingham stated: “I do accept that the loss of anonymity is a significa
The High Court has dismissed an appeal from the refusal of the Circuit Court to join the plaintiff’s sister as a co-plaintiff to his “proper provision” proceedings. Delivering judgment for the High Court, Ms Justice Siobhan Phelan that the six-month time limit to institute proceedi
The Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal of the parents of a newborn boy who died following a difficult birth. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice Charles Meenan observed that despite the appellants’ contention that the verdict of natural causes was incorrect, “no
The Supreme Court has determined that the use of a polygraph machine during psychological assessment in the wardship context was not oppressive, and that the trial judge was wrong to exclude evidence of confessions made by the respondent at interview. Delivering judgment for the Supreme Court, Mr Ju
The High Court has granted relief in judicial review of a decision of the District Court to reinstate driving charge following its spoken order dismissing the charge. Delivering judgment for the High Court, Mr Justice Barry O’Donnell determined that whilst the “breast of the court”
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal from orders granting summary judgment in which the appellant belatedly attempted to rely upon the O’Malley judgment. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice Donald Binchy determined that whilst the appellant was entitled to apply to i
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal against a High Court order granting discovery of post-accident medical records in a personal injuries claim. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Ms Justice Nuala Butler commented that “a party who wishes to rely on the availability of other
The Court of Appeal has quashed an assessment of the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (PIAB) for its failure to outline sums awarded for “dominant” and “lesser” injuries. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice Donald Binchy ruled that the appellant was enti
The Court of Appeal has allowed an appeal from the refusal of the High Court to grant reliefs sought by party with inadequate proofs. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice Senan Allen commented that in circumstances where the property sought to be charged was co-owned by the defend
Court of Appeal: Unsuccessful appellant succeeds in application to displace ‘usual rule’ as to costs
The Court of Appeal has decided that s.3 of the Environment (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2011 applied to proceedings brought unsuccessfully under s.160 of the Planning and Development Act 2000. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice Séamus Woulfe noted that the requirement
The High Court has granted continuing Mareva-type relief following the disposal of a statutory appeal from a determination order. Delivering judgment for the High Court, Ms Justice Niamh Hyland commented that “the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court includes a power to make orders that rem
The Court of Appeal has affirmed the decision of the High Court to lift an automatic suspension on a decision of the Minister for Transport awarding a search and rescue services contract to a new provider. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Ms Justice Caroline Costello remarked that the &l
The Court of Appeal has substituted an award of the High Court for personal injuries sustained by a cyclist involved in a road traffic accident with a bus. Delivering judgment for the Court of Appeal, Mr Justice Seamus Noonan found that the High Court had largely ignored the evidence tendered on beh
The High Court this month made an order for the indefinite detention of Enoch Burke after finding him in contempt of a court order. Delivering an ex tempore judgment for the High Court, Mr Justice Mark Heslin noted that court orders are not an “à la carte menu” and that a party su